It is an obligation for all schools to protect their students from bullying and to teach respect and openness. And policymakers and school management need to give strong support to teachers in order for them to have the means and resources to create a healthy and inclusive environment in schools and classrooms.
[27 September 2011] - In schools across Europe young persons are being harassed because of their sexual orientation or gender identity. Homophobic and transphobic bullying is an every day reality in the lives of many. It is time to react – especially in view of several national studies and reports warning that there have been a number of suicides among young lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender (LGBT) persons feeling rejected by their peers and families.
The scope of this problem appears to be large. A study in the United Kingdom showed that nine in ten secondary school teachers had witnessed children being subjected to homophobic bullying in their schools. Among primary school teachers two in five had made similar observations regarding children at this very early stage.
Such studies have also demonstrated that children in primary schools use homophobic remarks alarmingly often. They pick up and repeat negative jargon, most often without even understanding what the words refer to.
My recent report “Discrimination on grounds of sexual orientation and gender identity in Europe” contains numerous examples of how factually wrong information about LGBT persons is disseminated – sometimes also by schools themselves. This is a serious problem and may contribute to bullying and to cementing homophobic and transphobic attitudes.
School books used to spread prejudices
The World Health Organization removed homosexuality from the International Classification of Diseases in 1990. Despite this, prejudices and misunderstandings have too often lived on in teaching programmes.
Only this past summer was a decision taken in “the former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia” to revise a school textbook describing homosexuals as “neurotic and psychotic persons” with an “abnormal, unnatural and degenerated sexual life”. From Lithuania I have received information that children have been taught that homosexuality is a sickness and that same-sex relationships destroy families.
In 2009 the European Committee of Social Rights set an important standard in its review of a complaint against Croatia regarding the content of a school biology textbook which was held to contain prejudiced information. The Committee found that “Certain educational materials which are used in the regular teaching programme are biased, discriminatory and degrading.” Croatia withdrew the textbook as a result of the Committee’s findings, though NGOs in the country still report similar problems with other textbooks.
“Don’t stand for homophobic bullying”
Some member states have taken encouraging initiatives. A national action plan in Norway targets schools at both primary and secondary level and has added an LGBT dimension to subjects in the mainstream curriculum. In Estonia the national study curriculum provides a basis for discussions on LGB issues. UNESCO is initiating an international consultation on homophobic bullying in educational institutions. NGOs conduct indispensable anti-homophobic bullying campaigns such as the Irish ‘Don’t stand for homophobic bullying’ initiative.
There is a strong need to review curricula and teaching materials in all member states of the Council of Europe. This was also emphasised in a Council of Europe Committee of Ministers Recommendation which called on member states to provide “pupils and students with the necessary information, protection and support to enable them to live in accordance with their sexual orientation and gender identity.”
Schools obliged to protect students
It is an obligation for all schools to protect their students from bullying and to teach respect and openness. School personnel need thorough training concerning non-discrimination issues. One important tool in this regard could be the Council of Europe training pack on violence reduction in schools.
Policy makers and school management need to give strong support to teachers in order for them to have the means and resources to create a healthy and inclusive environment in schools and classrooms.
- Thomas Hammarberg
- The Commissioner’s thematic page on human rights of lesbian, gay, bisexual, and transgender persons (LGBT)
- HUMAN RIGHTS COMMENT: Clear laws needed to protect trans persons from discrimination and hatred (July 2011)
- UNITED KINGDOM: Faith schools are failing to challenge 'endemic' homophobia, teachers say (17 May 2011)
- LITHUANIA: Euro-Politicians Again Hit Out at Anti-Gay Proposals by Lithuanian MPs (20 January 2011)
- CRIN Editorial on DISCRIMINATION: Children and Sexuality (CRIN, May 2010)
- ALBANIA: Model law on LGBT discrimination passed (11 February 2010)
- LITHUANIA: New law bans discussion of homosexuality to 'protect minors' (4 June 2009)
- EUROPE: Homophobia and Discrimination on Grounds of Sexual Orientation and Gender Identity in the EU Member States (April 2009)
- UNITED KINGDOM: The experiences of young gay people in Britain's schools (June 2007)
- POLAND: Children's Commissioner targets 'gay' Teletubbies (29 May 2007)
- EUROPE: Human Rights Comment on Homophobia (16 May 2007)
- Child rights extracts from the Yogyakarta Principles on sexual orientation and gender identity
- HUMAN RIGHTS COMMENT: Human rights education must be a priority (October 2008)
- More Human Rights Comments by the Commissioner concerning children
Previous News release items
- 26/09/2011: IRELAND: Abuse of children in institutions amounts to torture
- 26/09/2011: ARMED CONFLICT: Pressure needed to end use of child soldiers
- 26/09/2011: NETHERLANDS: Police accused of ignoring child rights
- 26/09/2011: BOLIVIA: Gobierno reprime una marcha indígena
- 26/09/2011: IRLANDA: Amnistía Internacional califica de tortura los abusos infantiles cometidos por el Estado irlandés y la Iglesia católica
Organisation Contact Details:
Commissioner for Human Rights, Council of Europe
Commissioner for Human Rights
Council of Europe
F-67075 Strasbourg Cedex
Tel: +33 3 88 41 20 00
Last updated 27/09/2011 04:01:38